In civil and commercial transactions, deposits and advance payments are two important financial instruments, but they are often misunderstood, leading to disputes when the parties involved are unclear about their nature and legal consequences. A clearly distinction between deposits and advance payments not only helps parties choose the appropriate method but also minimizes legal risks when entering into contracts. In this article, TNTP will analyze the differences between deposits and advance payments in contracts.
1. Definition of deposit and advance payment
• Deposit is a security measure to ensure contract performance. According to Article 328 of the Civil Code 2015, a deposit is an amount of money or other assets given by one party to the other to guarantee the performance of a contract. If the contract is properly performed, the deposit will be refunded or deducted from the payment obligation. However, if the depositor breaches their obligation, the deposit will belong to the recipient. If the recipient breaches the agreement, they must return the deposit, unless otherwise agreed.
• Advance payment is not explicitly defined by law. However, it can be understood as a sum of money paid in advance by the buyer or service user to the seller or service provider before the contract is performed to fulfill contractual obligations. Unlike a deposit, an advance payment does not serve as a security for contract performance but a partial prepayment of a financial obligation agreed upon.
2. Differences in purpose between deposit and advance payment
• Deposit serves as a security measure to ensure contract performance. It is one of the securities designed to guarantee the performance of the obligation, with potential penalties applied in case of a breach.
• Advance payment, on the other hand, is not a security measure for contract performance. It is simply a prepayment for a financial obligation agreed upon by the parties.
3. Differences in legal consequences between deposit and advance payment
• For deposit: If the contract is breached or not fully performed, the deposited amount or asset will belong to the recipient of the deposit or must be returned to the deposit party, depends on the situation. This mechanism encourages parties to fulfill their contractual obligations accurately and completely, reducing the likelihood of violations.
• For advance payment: If the contract is not performed, the party receiving the advance payment is obligated to return the amount according to the terms of the signed contract or any other agreements between the parties.
In the event of a dispute or contract termination, the advance payment is typically refundable unless otherwise agreed. If the receiving party has partially fulfilled their obligations or delivered part of the goods/services, the refundable amount may be adjusted according to the completed obligations or delivered goods/services.
• If the nature of the transferred amount cannot be clearly determined, according to Article 37 of Decree 21/2021/NĐ-CP, when one party transfers a sum of money to the other without specifying whether it is a deposit or an advance payment, the amount is considered an advance payment.
4. Cases where deposit and advance payment apply
• When to use a deposit:
– When one party wants to create a mechanism that compels the other party to fulfill their contractual obligations as agreed.
– When the parties need a stronger securities measure with penal consequences to reduce risks arising from contract violations.
– Example: In a real estate purchase agreement, the buyer typically places a deposit to ensure the seller does not sell the property to another party or change their decision.
• When to use an advance payment:
– When the transferred amount is merely a partial prepayment of a financial obligation under the contract.
– When the parties do not intend for the payment to serve as a guarantee for contract performance.
– Example: In a construction contract, the project owner may advance a sum to the contractor to purchase materials and begin construction.
5. Notes on applying deposit and advance payment
• In practice, when disputes arise, determining the nature of the financial arrangement and its corresponding legal consequences can be complex, especially if the parties did not explicitly define the nature of the payment. A common issue is when one party seeks to enforce penalties associated with a deposit, while the other claims it was merely an advance payment. In such cases, dispute resolution authorities will consider multiple factors, including the parties’ intent at the time of contract formation, the agreement’s content, commitments, and the method of performance to determine whether the payment was a deposit or an advance.
To avoid disputes and protect their rights, the parties should clearly specify the nature of the transferred amount in the contract. This can be achieved by explicitly stating whether the payment is a deposit or an advance, along with provisions outlining the legal consequences in case of a contractual breach.
• Additionally, the parties should clearly express their intentions through the contract terms, including conditions for refund, liabilities in case of breach, and applicable penalties. For instance, if the payment is a deposit, the contract should clearly state the consequences of non-performance, such as forfeiture of the deposit or compensation obligations. Conversely, if the payment is an advance, the contract should outline the refund conditions or how the amount will be deducted from future payments.
Furthermore, the use of supporting documents, such as payment transfer records, receipts, or separate agreements regarding deposits or advances, can help clarify the parties’ intentions. This approach not only mitigates legal risks but also provides a strong basis for protecting one’s rights in case of disputes.
In summary, clearly distinguishing between deposits and advance payments is crucial in commercial transactions to minimize disputes, ensure transparency, and safeguard the legal rights of contracting parties.
The choice between a deposit and an advance payment depends on the contract’s purpose and nature. Understanding the differences between these two mechanisms will help businesses and individuals mitigate legal risks and secure their contractual interests.
This article “Differences between deposit and advance payment in contracts” is presented by TNTP. We hope this provides valuable insights to our readers.
Best regards,
