Skip to main content

Illegal Debt Collection in Vietnam: Prohibited Practices and Penalties

In Vietnam, creditors may lawfully recover debts, but only through methods the law permits. Debt collection becomes illegal when the creditor, or anyone acting for it, harasses, threatens, insults, publicly exposes, uses force against or seizes property from the debtor or related persons. Such conduct may lead to administrative sanctions, criminal liability and civil compensation. It can also apply even when the debt genuinely exists.

Separately, the business of providing coercive debt collection services is a prohibited business line. Creditors therefore need to know both which practices are prohibited and which lawful routes remain available.

What counts as illegal debt collection in Vietnam?

Debt recovery is a lawful right of creditors, but this right is not absolute. It must be exercised within the limits permitted by law. Excessive pressure, or measures that infringe upon the lawful rights and interests of others, can turn lawful debt recovery into illegal debt collection.

Illegal debt collection practices are acts of demanding payment, exerting pressure or using threatening measures that infringe upon the life, health, honor, dignity, property, privacy or other lawful rights and interests of the person having payment obligations, or of related persons.

In business, receivables and delayed payments are unavoidable. When cash flow is tied up, creditors naturally want to recover outstanding amounts quickly to minimize losses. In practice, however, many individuals and enterprises, through impatience or a lack of legal understanding, adopt excessively coercive measures. Many of them not only fail to recover the money but also face administrative sanctions or criminal liability because of the method they chose.

The boundary between lawful and illegal collection

The key difference does not lie in whether the debt actually exists. It lies in the manner in which the creditor requires the debtor to perform its payment obligations.

Within the legal framework, creditors may protect their rights through negotiation, reconciliation of outstanding balances, payment demand letters, representation by lawyers, and dispute resolution through arbitration or the courts, followed by enforcement procedures. These methods are recognized by law to compel debtors to perform their obligations in a lawful and orderly manner.

By contrast, illegal debt collection uses measures that infringe upon the property, honor, dignity, privacy, freedom or other lawful rights and interests of debtors or related persons in order to pressure them into paying. The unlawful element arises not from the request for payment itself, but from the way the request is carried out.

Is debt collection itself legal in Vietnam?

Yes. Vietnamese law does not prohibit creditors from recovering debts or enforcing their right to demand payment through lawful means. What is prohibited under Point h, Clause 1, Article 6 of the Law on Investment 2025 is the business of providing coercive debt collection services. This line was abolished as a separate business line because of concerns over widespread abuses and unlawful practices. The debt collection service business has been officially banned since 1 January 2021.

The concepts of “debt recovery” and “coercive debt collection services” should not be treated as the same:

  • Debt recovery is the lawful exercise by a creditor of its right to demand payment through legally recognized measures, such as negotiation, written payment demands, representation by lawyers, arbitration, court proceedings and enforcement procedures.
  • Coercive debt collection services refers to a former conditional business sector under Vietnamese law, in which third parties were engaged to collect debts on behalf of creditors. Because of widespread abuses and the increasing use of coercive, intimidating and unlawful methods, this business was ultimately prohibited.

The prohibition is therefore aimed at the business of coercive debt collection services as a business line and at unlawful collection practices. It does not target the legitimate right of creditors to recover debts lawfully. Businesses may still use legal services provided by lawyers or law firms for negotiation, representation, dispute resolution and enforcement proceedings. For a fuller analysis, see whether debt recovery companies are legal in Vietnam.

Current law does not provide a separate, exhaustive list of prohibited acts in debt recovery. This does not mean creditors are free to use any method they choose. The practices below are prohibited because they infringe upon personal rights and property rights protected by law. Depending on the nature and severity of the violation, they may be subject to administrative sanctions or criminal prosecution.

Prohibited debt collection practices and their penalties

1. Publishing the debtor’s images or personal information without consent

When a debtor fails to pay on time, some creditors immediately publicize the debtor’s personal information, such as name, age, date of birth, identity card number, address of residence and workplace. Images and information about the debtor’s family and relatives are sometimes also disclosed on social networks, on the internet, in residential areas or in other public places, without the debtor’s consent. This is one of the most common illegal debt collection practices.

Disclosing the debtor’s images and information means distributing information to a third party without the consent of the owner of that personal information. Such conduct:

  • is subject to administrative sanctions under Clause 2, Article 84 of Decree No. 15/2020/ND-CP on sanctioning administrative violations in the fields of post, telecommunications, radio frequencies, information technology and electronic transactions (“Decree No. 15”); and
  • may lead to criminal prosecution under Point b, Clause 1, Article 288 of the Criminal Code 2015 (amended and supplemented in 2017) for the crime of illegally providing or using information on computer networks or telecommunications networks, if the elements of the crime are met.

Public exposure also reduces the debtor’s goodwill and willingness to pay. The risks of shaming a debtor online are discussed further in defaming a debtor on social networks and its consequences.

2. Insulting or defaming the debtor’s honor and dignity

After repeated unsuccessful contact, some creditors, out of anger and frustration, insult the debtor, defame the debtor’s honor and dignity or use vulgar language. A breach of a civil agreement by the debtor does not give the creditor the right to insult or smear the debtor. In practice, many criminal cases begin with a creditor swearing at a debtor. As a result, the creditor fails to recover the debt and is reported by the debtor for violating the law.

  • Administrative sanctions apply under Point a, Clause 3, Article 7 of Decree No. 144/2021/ND-CP on sanctioning administrative violations in the fields of social security, order and safety; prevention and control of social evils; fire prevention and fighting; rescue; and prevention and control of domestic violence (“Decree No. 144”).
  • Criminal liability may arise under Article 155 of the Criminal Code 2015 for the crime of humiliating other persons.

3. Contacting the debtor’s relatives or acquaintances to demand payment

Calling or contacting the debtor’s acquaintances, friends or family members to ask them to pay on the debtor’s behalf is a typical illegal practice, particularly among financial companies whose debtors lack the ability to pay. For financial companies engaged in consumer lending, this conduct is prohibited by Circular No. 18/2019/TT-NHNN amending and supplementing Circular No. 43/2016/TT-NHNN of the Governor of the State Bank of Vietnam on consumer lending by financial companies (“Circular No. 18”).

In principle, the debtor is the only party obliged to pay the debt. The creditor may not require unrelated persons to pay. A creditor may demand payment from a third party only where the debtor, the third party and the creditor have agreed that the third party takes over the payment obligation. The rules on transferring the right to claim a debt are covered in whether the right to debt collection can be assigned.

4. Threatening or using violence, or damaging the debtor’s property

Threatening to use violence, using violence or destroying another person’s property is always unlawful, in debt collection or otherwise. Yet creditors who lose control of their emotions sometimes smash property, curse or use force to make the debtor pay. They may not hit, tie up or detain the debtor to demand payment.

  • Using violence, threatening to use violence or using other measures not permitted by law to collect debts violates Point d, Clause 4, Article 12 of Decree No. 144.
  • Destroying or intentionally damaging another person’s property violates Point c, Clause 4, Article 15 of Decree No. 144.
  • Using violence may lead to criminal prosecution under Article 134 of the Criminal Code 2015 for the crime of intentionally causing bodily harm if the debtor suffers a bodily injury rate of 11% or more.
  • Destroying property may lead to criminal prosecution under Article 178 of the Criminal Code 2015 for the crime of destroying or intentionally damaging property if the damaged property is worth VND 2,000,000 or more.

These acts infringe upon the life and health of the debtor and also risk disrupting social order and safety.

5. Calling or messaging excessively

Contacting a debtor to request payment by phone, text message or letter is a creditor’s right. However, calls or messages made with excessive frequency, in a harassing or threatening manner, or in a way that seriously affects the debtor’s life and normal activities may still be subject to legal sanctions.

For financial companies, Clause 7, Article 1 of Circular No. 18 allows debt reminders up to 5 times per day, only between 7 a.m. and 9 p.m. Reminders beyond that number or outside that period are illegal debt collection practices.

6. Seizing the debtor’s property or applying coercive measures without authority

Only enforcement agencies have the competence to forcibly take the money and assets of a judgment debtor to pay the creditor, after the creditor’s claim has been determined by the court. A creditor may not use coercive measures to take the debtor’s money or assets to offset the debt without the debtor’s permission.

Creditors are likewise not permitted to unlawfully enter residences or workplaces, gather crowds at the debtor’s residence or workplace, or obstruct the normal activities of the individual or organization owing payment. Self-help measures such as retaining property, locking premises, or cutting off electricity or water supplies are coercive measures that only competent state authorities may apply.

7. Engaging a debt collection service provider or unqualified persons

Because the debt collection service business has been banned since 1 January 2021, a creditor may not authorize a third party practicing debt collection services to take recovery measures against the debtor. Hiring or authorizing other persons to collect through methods that do not comply with the law, or assigning the work to persons lacking expertise, can lead to conduct beyond permissible limits and increases the risk for the creditor itself.

Summary of sanctions

Practice Administrative basis Possible criminal liability
Publishing personal information or images without consent Clause 2, Article 84, Decree No. 15 Point b, Clause 1, Article 288, Criminal Code 2015
Insulting or defaming the debtor Point a, Clause 3, Article 7, Decree No. 144 Article 155, Criminal Code 2015
Contacting relatives or acquaintances (financial companies) Prohibited by Circular No. 18 —
Threatening or using violence to collect debts Point d, Clause 4, Article 12, Decree No. 144 Article 134, Criminal Code 2015 (injury rate of 11% or more)
Destroying or damaging property Point c, Clause 4, Article 15, Decree No. 144 Article 178, Criminal Code 2015 (property worth VND 2,000,000 or more)
Excessive debt reminders (financial companies) Clause 7, Article 1, Circular No. 18: max. 5 times per day, 7 a.m. to 9 p.m. —

Consequences of illegal debt collection

Depending on the nature, severity and consequences of the violation, illegal debt collection may lead to:

  • Administrative sanctions: for acts infringing upon honor and dignity, disclosing personal information or causing public disorder.
  • Criminal liability: in more serious cases, such as extortion, threats, humiliating others, disturbing public order, unlawful intrusion into residences or intentionally causing bodily harm. Threats, coercion or violence during debt collection may give rise to criminal liability for various offenses under the Criminal Code, with penalties such as fines or imprisonment.
  • Civil liability: in addition to liability toward the State, violators may be required to compensate affected parties for damages in accordance with civil law.
  • Failed recovery: unlawful pressure reduces the debtor’s goodwill and often leaves the creditor exposed to complaints and reports instead of payment.

These risks apply both to those who carry out illegal collection and to the businesses that use them. At a broader level, the spread of illegal collection has led the public to view all debt collection as unlawful and associated with organized crime. This misperception discourages creditors from pursuing debts they are lawfully entitled to recover.

Where a debt is large, disputed or long overdue, creditors can engage TNTP’s lawful debt recovery services to apply legal pressure without these risks.

How to recover debts lawfully

To ensure effectiveness and avoid legal risks, businesses should prioritize professional debt recovery measures with a clear roadmap.

  1. Review the documents. Collect and check all documents relating to the debt, including contracts, invoices, delivery records, acceptance minutes, debt reconciliation records and correspondence between the parties.
  2. Negotiate and send written demands. Conduct negotiations, send written payment demands and fully document the working process.
  3. Involve lawyers early for complex or long-overdue debts. Lawyers help formulate an appropriate strategy, create lawful legal pressure and prepare a solid legal basis if the matter proceeds to dispute.
  4. Resolve the dispute through arbitration or the courts, then enforce. Arbitration, court proceedings and enforcement procedures are the lawful routes when the debtor still does not pay. See the court procedures for filing a corporate debt recovery lawsuit.

Common mistakes that turn debt recovery into illegal collection

  • Having no strategy and failing to prepare sufficient documents and evidence before dealing with debtors, so that the process becomes argumentative, emotional and prone to uncontrolled conduct.
  • Hiring or authorizing other persons to recover debts through methods that do not comply with the law, or assigning the work to individuals or organizations lacking expertise.
  • Letting emotions dominate, leading to threats, insults, harassment or excessive pressure beyond what the law permits.
  • Unilaterally applying coercive measures that only competent state authorities may apply, such as retaining property, locking premises, cutting off electricity or water supplies, or obstructing the debtor’s normal operations.

What to do when facing illegal debt collection

Individuals and businesses subjected to unlawful collection methods should not respond with similar conduct. They should:

  • stay calm and collect and preserve evidence, such as messages, recordings, photographs, videos, call histories and other relevant documents;
  • where the conduct involves threats, insults or infringements upon property or health, report the matter to the police or request competent authorities to handle it in accordance with the law.

Frequently asked questions

Is it illegal to call a debtor repeatedly to demand payment?

Contacting a debtor to request payment is a creditor’s right. However, calls made with excessive frequency, in a harassing or threatening manner, or in a way that adversely affects another person’s normal life may be subject to legal sanctions. Financial companies may send debt reminders up to 5 times per day, between 7 a.m. and 9 p.m., under Circular No. 18.

Can a creditor post information about a debtor online?

No. Publicly disclosing personal information, images or insulting content to pressure debtors may result in administrative, civil or even criminal liability, depending on the seriousness of the violation.

Are debt collection services legal in Vietnam?

No. Under current regulations, coercive debt collection services are a prohibited business line. Businesses may still use legal services provided by lawyers or law firms to recover debts through negotiation, representation, dispute resolution and enforcement proceedings in accordance with the law.

Can threatening a debtor lead to criminal liability?

Yes. Depending on the nature and severity of the conduct, threats, coercion or violence during debt collection may give rise to criminal liability for various offenses under the Criminal Code.

Can a creditor ask the debtor’s relatives to pay?

Only where the debtor, the third party and the creditor have agreed that the third party takes over the payment obligation. Otherwise, the debtor alone is obliged to pay.

Conclusion

Debt recovery is a lawful right of creditors, but it must be exercised within the framework of the law. Impatience or an improper method not only reduces the likelihood of recovering the money but may also expose creditors to serious legal risks. Businesses should prioritize lawful, systematic and strategically planned solutions. Involving lawyers or legal advisors from the outset helps protect the creditor’s rights and maximizes the effectiveness of debt recovery in practice. TNTP’s debt recovery and dispute resolution team can assist with this process.

TNTP & ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL LAW FIRM

  • Office in Ho Chi Minh City:
    Room no. 1901, 19 th Floor Saigon Trade Center Tower, No. 37 Ton Duc Thang Street, Saigon Ward, Ho Chi Minh City
  • Office in Hanoi City:
    No. 2, Alley 308, Tay Son Street, Dong Da Ward, Hanoi City

The copyright belongs to: TNTP & Associates International Law Firm