Skip to main content

Arbitration vs Litigation in Vietnam: Choosing Court or Arbitration

| TNTP LAW |

In Vietnam, a commercial dispute that cannot be settled by negotiation or conciliation goes either to the People’s Court or to commercial arbitration. Court litigation is the default route: fees are lower, advance fees can be refunded to a winning claimant, and judgments are enforced by the State. Arbitration is available only where the parties have a valid arbitration agreement, but it is confidential, faster, decided at a single level, and its awards are recognised internationally under the New York Convention.

For a foreign business with a Vietnamese customer or partner, the choice usually turns on five points: whether an arbitration agreement exists, the need for confidentiality, the acceptable time frame, the budget, and where the decision will have to be enforced. This article compares the two routes on each point and explains when each one fits.

Arbitration vs litigation in Vietnam at a glance

Criterion People’s Court Commercial arbitration
Legal nature Judicial body of the State, exercising judicial power Non-governmental, of a social and professional nature; ad hoc or through an Arbitration Center
When available Default forum for virtually all types of disputes Only where the parties have an arbitration agreement, made before or after the dispute arises
Choice of forum The competent Court is fixed by the Civil Procedure Code, except where the Code allows the claimant to choose Parties choose any Arbitration Center or ad hoc arbitration, and choose the arbitrators
Confidentiality Public trial as a principle; closed hearings only in the cases listed in Article 15 of the Civil Procedure Code 2015 Non-public hearings; facts and the award are not published without the parties’ consent
Levels of review First instance and appeal; legally effective judgments may also be reviewed by cassation or retrial Single level; the award is final and cannot be appealed, but may be annulled by the Court under Articles 68 and 69 of the Law on Commercial Arbitration 2010
Time Several stages; from filing to judgment can take several years Flexible procedure; parties can shape time and venue to speed up settlement
Cost Lower advance court fees; refunded in full if the claim is accepted in whole Claimant pays the full arbitration costs set by the Center, much higher than court advance fees; refunds depend on the Center’s rules
Language and applicable law Governed by the law on civil procedure Parties may choose the language and the applicable law where the dispute has a foreign element
Enforcement in Vietnam Binding and enforced by the civil judgment enforcement agencies Enforced by the civil judgment enforcement agencies on request if not performed voluntarily; often more complex than enforcing a judgment
Enforcement abroad Recognition in another country is commonly difficult and depends on bilateral agreements and strict rules Recognised internationally under the New York Convention 1958

Legal nature: State power or party agreement

The Court is the judicial body of the State and exercises judicial power. During the proceedings, the Court, on behalf of the State, considers and settles the dispute in order to maintain public order and protect the legitimate rights and interests of the parties. Its judgments and decisions compel the parties to perform their obligations, even by physical force.

Arbitration is a non-governmental method of dispute settlement, of a social and professional nature. Under Clause 1, Article 3 of the Law on Commercial Arbitration 2010, commercial arbitration is a mode of dispute settlement agreed upon by the parties and conducted in accordance with that Law. Disputes may be settled by ad hoc arbitration or by an Arbitration Center, which is established on the basis of an agreement of arbitrators and approval from State authorities.

Arbitration is not part of the State apparatus and is not a judicial body of the State. Because it does not represent the judicial power of the State, it is well suited to resolving disputes involving foreign factors.

The two mechanisms also differ in how they apply. Arbitration is a mechanism the parties select. The Court is the default mechanism that applies whenever the parties have not agreed on another one.

Jurisdiction: which disputes each forum can hear

Jurisdiction by type of case

The Court has broader jurisdiction than arbitration. Courts resolve virtually all types of disputes, including business and commercial, inheritance, marriage and family, and tort disputes.

Arbitration resolves only the following disputes:

  • disputes between parties arising from commercial activities;
  • disputes arising between parties of which at least one party has commercial activities;
  • other disputes between parties that the law provides must be settled by arbitration.

Even for these disputes, the parties may refer the case to arbitration only if they have an arbitration agreement, made before or after the dispute arises. The arbitration agreement is the indispensable condition for initiating arbitration proceedings. The terms that make such a clause work are covered in our guide to key points in arbitration agreements.

When the Court must refuse the case

Before filing a lawsuit, the claimant needs to determine whether the Court has jurisdiction and whether the parties have an arbitration agreement. If the parties have an arbitration agreement but one of them still sues in Court, the Court has no jurisdiction and must refuse to accept the case, unless the arbitration agreement is invalid or cannot be performed.

Territorial jurisdiction and choice of forum

In court proceedings, territorial jurisdiction is set out clearly and in detail in the Civil Procedure Code. A petition is settled only when it is filed with the competent Court as prescribed by law, except where the Code allows the claimant to choose the Court.

Arbitration has no territorial jurisdiction. The parties may choose any Arbitration Center according to their wishes and its credibility, and the Center they agree on is entitled to accept the dispute. For example, where both parties have their business headquarters in Hanoi, they may agree on an arbitration center in Hanoi to facilitate the proceedings.

Confidentiality: public trial vs private hearing

The Court adjudicates not only to protect the rights and interests of the parties but also to educate the public in observing the law. Most trials are therefore held in public, and judgments are often made public. This makes it difficult to protect confidential business information and can affect a company’s reputation and its relationship with the other party.

Courts may hold trials behind closed doors only in special cases: to keep State secrets, preserve the nation’s fine customs and practices, protect minors, or keep the professional, business or personal secrets of the parties at their legitimate request (Article 15 of the Civil Procedure Code 2015).

In arbitration, the whole process is confidential unless the parties agree otherwise. The law does not require arbitration hearings to be public, and the hearing takes place with the participation of the parties only. Facts and results are not published without the parties’ consent, and the arbitral award is not made public unless the parties request it.

Keeping the dispute and the identities of the parties private supports trust in commercial relations. This is particularly significant in competitive markets, for companies listed on stock exchanges, and in disputes involving trade secrets, inventions or other matters the parties need to keep confidential.

Time and finality: levels of trial and appeal

Court: first instance, appeal, cassation and retrial

Court proceedings follow a two-level adjudication regime: first instance and appeal. A party that disagrees with a first-instance judgment or decision may appeal within the prescribed time limit. Judgments and decisions that have taken legal effect may also be reviewed under cassation or retrial procedures, so the outcome may still change.

Because the case must pass through several stages, the time from filing the petition to the issuance of a judgment or decision can extend to several years. Businesses often try to avoid this.

The basic steps of court proceedings are:

  1. The plaintiff sues the respondent at the competent Court.
  2. Pre-litigation mediation.
  3. A session to check the handover of, access to and disclosure of evidence, and conciliation.
  4. First-instance trial, followed by appeal where a party appeals.

Arbitration: one level, final award

Arbitration hears a business or commercial dispute only once. The arbitral award is final, binding on the parties and cannot be appealed, and it has the same validity as a court judgment or decision. This follows from the nature of arbitration: the parties chose it by their own will and right of disposition, so they must comply with the final award. Avoiding further levels of trial saves time and money.

The procedure is also flexible. The parties can take the initiative on the time and venue of the proceedings to speed up settlement, select the arbitral tribunal and, where the dispute has a foreign element, choose the language of the proceedings and the law applicable to the dispute.

The basic steps at an Arbitration Center are:

  1. The claimant submits the statement of claim to the Arbitration Center.
  2. The claimant and the respondent choose arbitrators.
  3. Documents and evidence are investigated and collected.
  4. The arbitral tribunal announces the date of the hearing.
  5. The parties attend the hearing.
  6. The arbitral award is issued.

Choosing the arbitrators

The right to appoint arbitrators lets the parties select trusted experts with professional standing and practical experience in the subject of the dispute, for example insurance, shares and securities, or construction. This supports prompt and accurate settlement based on the voluntary and free agreement of the parties.

The limit on finality: annulment by the Court

Although final, an arbitral award may be annulled by the Court at the request of one party under Articles 68 and 69 of the Law on Commercial Arbitration 2010. The grounds and the process are explained in our guide to the annulment of an arbitral award in Vietnam.

Cost: court fees vs arbitration fees

After the Court receives the petition, the plaintiff must pay an advance on court fees and charges. At judgment, the Court determines the court fees on the principle that the losing party bears them. If the plaintiff’s claims are accepted in whole, the plaintiff is not liable for court fees and charges, and the enforcement authority refunds the advance paid. A plaintiff that wins therefore does not lose the advance. The refund may be partial or full depending on the Court’s judgment or decision.

In arbitration, the claimant must pay the entire arbitration costs to the Arbitration Center when filing. The Center sets these costs, and the more reputable the Center, the higher they usually are. In practice, the arbitration costs payable by the claimant are much higher than the advance court fees in litigation.

The losing party normally bears the arbitration costs, unless the parties agree otherwise, the arbitration rules provide otherwise, or the arbitral tribunal allocates them differently. Any reimbursement depends on the rules of each Arbitration Center and may not equal the refund available in court. If the claimant wins but the award cannot be enforced against the respondent, the claimant effectively bears the arbitration costs it paid. A claimant should weigh this before initiating arbitration.

Enforcement in Vietnam and abroad

Enforcing a court judgment

Court judgments and decisions are binding and their enforcement is guaranteed by the judgment enforcement agencies. Within Vietnam, a judgment is usually more readily enforced than an arbitral award.

Across borders the position is different. A national court’s judgment is rooted in one country’s jurisdiction, so it is commonly difficult to have it recognised in another country; recognition generally requires a bilateral agreement and is subject to very strict rules.

Enforcing an arbitral award

The State encourages the parties to perform an arbitral award voluntarily. Where the time limit for performance has expired, the party bound by the award has not performed it voluntarily and has not requested annulment under Article 69 of the Law on Commercial Arbitration 2010, the party entitled under the award may apply to the competent civil judgment enforcement agency for enforcement.

For an ad hoc arbitral award, the entitled party may apply for enforcement only after the award has been registered in accordance with Article 62 of the Law on Commercial Arbitration 2010. Enforcement is carried out under the law on civil judgment enforcement and is often more complex than enforcing a court judgment.

Internationally, arbitral awards benefit from a wide range of international conventions, in particular the New York Convention 1958 on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards, with 150 countries and territories as parties. For a foreign creditor, this is a key reason to prefer arbitration in cross-border contracts. The Vietnamese side of that process is covered in our guide to enforcement of foreign arbitral awards in Vietnam.

Advantages and disadvantages of each route

Court litigation

Advantages:

  • Judgments and decisions are usually more enforceable than arbitral awards.
  • Court fees and advance fees are lower than arbitration fees.
  • The advance fee may be partially or fully refunded under the Court’s judgment or decision.
  • Public trial has a deterrent effect.

Disadvantages:

  • The procedure is not flexible and must follow the law on civil procedure.
  • The competent Court is determined by the law on civil procedure, not by the parties.
  • Settlement usually takes longer than arbitration.
  • Public trial can affect the parties’ relationship, their image and reputation in the market, and their business secrets.

Commercial arbitration

Advantages:

  • Based on the agreement of the parties, who choose ad hoc arbitration or an Arbitration Center and the arbitrators.
  • Flexible procedure and quick settlement.
  • The award is final, not subject to appeal, and has the same validity as a court judgment or decision.
  • Confidentiality, because hearings are not public unless the parties agree otherwise.

Disadvantages:

  • Arbitration fees are much higher than court fees.
  • Investigating, verifying and collecting evidence and applying interim urgent measures is more time-consuming and limited than in court.
  • The award may be annulled by the Court at the request of one party.
  • Enforcement of awards is often more complex than enforcement of court judgments.

Whether these trade-offs favour arbitration for a smaller company is discussed in should SMEs choose arbitration to resolve disputes.

Which route fits a dispute with a Vietnamese party

There is no single best forum. The decision should take into account the specific characteristics of the dispute, its legal nature and content, and the business situation of the parties. Based on the comparison above:

  • Check the contract first. If it contains a valid and performable arbitration agreement, the dispute goes to arbitration and the Court will refuse the case. If it does not, the Court is the default forum unless the parties agree on arbitration after the dispute arises.
  • Arbitration tends to fit when confidentiality matters, when the dispute has a foreign element, when the parties want to choose the language, applicable law and expert arbitrators, when speed matters, and when the decision may need to be enforced outside Vietnam.
  • The Court tends to fit when cost is a priority, when the claimant wants to recover the advance fee on winning, when evidence collection or interim measures by the State are important.
  • Assess recoverability before filing. In arbitration, a claimant that wins but cannot enforce the award still bears the arbitration costs it has paid.

TNTP advises foreign and Vietnamese businesses on drafting dispute resolution clauses, choosing the forum and representing clients before Vietnamese courts and arbitration centers. Learn more about our commercial dispute lawyer services in Vietnam.

Frequently asked questions

Are litigation and arbitration the same thing?

No. Litigation is conducted by the People’s Court, a judicial body exercising State power, and is the default forum for virtually all disputes. Arbitration is a non-governmental method that the parties must agree to, and it covers commercial disputes only.

Why is arbitration preferred over litigation in commercial disputes?

Businesses choose arbitration for its flexible procedure, confidentiality, the right to appoint expert arbitrators, a single final level of decision, and international recognition of awards under the New York Convention 1958. The trade-off is higher fees and more complex enforcement.

Can an arbitral award be appealed in Vietnam?

No. The award is final and binding. However, a party may ask the Court to annul it under Articles 68 and 69 of the Law on Commercial Arbitration 2010.

Can a Vietnamese court hear a case when the contract has an arbitration clause?

No. The Court must refuse to accept the case, unless the arbitration agreement is invalid or cannot be performed.

Which is cheaper, court or arbitration?

Court litigation. Advance court fees are lower than arbitration costs and are refunded if the claim is accepted in whole. In arbitration, the claimant pays the full costs set by the Arbitration Center up front.

TNTP & ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL LAW FIRM

  • Office in Ho Chi Minh City:
    Room no. 1901, 19 th Floor Saigon Trade Center Tower, No. 37 Ton Duc Thang Street, Saigon Ward, Ho Chi Minh City
  • Office in Hanoi City:
    No. 2, Alley 308, Tay Son Street, Dong Da Ward, Hanoi City

The copyright belongs to: TNTP & Associates International Law Firm