Skip to main content

Penalty for breach in construction contracts: legal framework and conditions for application

| TNTP LAW |

In construction contracts, penalties for breach are one of the most commonly applied remedies, aimed at deterrence, prevention, and compensation for indirect losses suffered by the non-breaching party. However, in practice, the application of this remedy is not simply a matter of agreement between the parties, but is also governed by a multi-layered legal framework, including civil law, commercial law and construction-specific legislation.

In this article, TNTP provides Readers with an overview of the latest legal framework and key considerations when drafting and implementing penalty for breach in construction contracts.

1.Legal regulations on penalties for breach in construction contracts

Under general principles of civil law, a penalty for breach is a contractual remedy agreed upon by the parties, whereby the non-breaching party can require the breaching party to pay a penalty amount due to contractual violations. The nature of this penalty is pre-agreed, serving as a deterrent and an incentive for proper contractual performance. The parties are free to agree on whether or not to apply such penalties.

Currently, penalties for breach in construction contracts are governed by the Civil Code 2015, the Commercial Law 2005, and the Construction Law 2025 (effective from July 01, 2026). However, these legal instruments are not yet consistent in determining the maximum penalty level.

Specifically, Article 418 of the Civil Code 2015 does not impose a specific ceiling on penalty amounts, instead allowing parties to freely agree on such amounts. This approach reflects the principle of freedom of contract, allowing parties to determine penalty levels appropriate to the nature and risk of the transaction.

In contrast, Article 301 of the Commercial Law 2005 establishes a clear limit, providing that the penalty must not exceed 8% of the value of the breached contractual obligation. This provision aims to control the application of penalties in commercial relationships and prevent excessive penalties that may disrupt the balance of interests between parties.

In the construction sector, specialized legislation provides sector-specific regulations. Specifically, under Article 86 of the Construction Law 2025, penalties for breach must be agreed upon and clearly stipulated in the contract. In the absence of such agreement, the penalty clause may not be enforceable. For construction works under public investment projects or public-private partnership (PPP) projects, the penalty must not exceed 12% of the value of the breached part of the construction contract. This regulation ensures a balance of interests and prevents abuse of penalty for breach in practice.

2.Conditions for applying penalties for breach in construction contracts

In construction contracts, penalties for breach are a pre-agreed remedy that only arise when all contractual and legal conditions are satisfied. Therefore, correctly identifying these conditions is essential to ensuring the validity of penalty for breach and minimizing disputes during contract performance.

First, a prerequisite for applying penalties is the existence of a penalty agreement in the construction contract. In principle, penalties are not automatically applied but must be clearly stipulated by the parties. The clause should specify the acts of breach, the penalty amount, and the calculation method. If the contract does not contain such an agreement, the non-breaching party, even if having suffered losses, has no legal basis to claim penalties.

The penalty agreement may be established at the time of contract formation or supplemented during the performance of the contract through appendices or amendments. However, all agreements must comply with applicable specialized laws. In construction contracts, particularly those involving state-owned capital, penalty levels are limited by law. If the agreed penalty exceeds such limits, the excess portion will not be recognized in the event of dispute, and the penalty will only be enforced within the limits permitted by laws.

Second, penalties only arise when there is an actual breach of contractual obligations. In other words, an agreement on penalties alone does not give rise to liability unless a specific breach has occurred. In construction contracts, breaches typically relate to core obligations such as construction progress, work quality, payment obligations, or warranty obligations. When a party fails to perform or improperly performs these obligations, and such breach falls within the scope of the penalty clause, the penalty will apply.

Third, the breach must not fall under cases of exemption from liability under the contract or by law. Pursuant to Clause 1, Article 294 of the Commercial Law 2005, a breaching party may be exempt from liability in the following cases:

(i) Occurrence of agreed exemption events

The parties may pre-agree on circumstances that exempt liability. This reflects contractual freedom, allowing parties to allocate risks during the implementation of the project.

(ii) Occurrence of force majeure events

These are events occurring objective, unforeseeable, and unavoidable despite all necessary measures being taken. In construction activities, force majeure events include: (i) natural disasters and environmental catastrophes; (ii) fires and epidemics; (iii) states of emergency related to national security, public order, or national defense; (iv) strikes, lockouts, embargoes, or blockades; (v) archaeological discoveries; and (vi) other cases as prescribed by relevant laws.

(iii) The breach is entirely attributable to the fault of the other party

In such cases, applying penalties would be inconsistent with fairness principles in contractual relationships. If the breaching party is only partially at fault, liability for penalties will be determined proportionally to the degree of fault. This principle is commonly applied in dispute resolution to ensure fairness.

(iv) The breach results from compliance with decisions of competent state authorities that the parties could not have known or anticipated at the time of contract execution

In construction, this may involve planning adjustments, suspension of construction, or policy changes affecting contract performance.

Finally, it should be emphasized that the burden of proof for exemption from liability rests with the breaching party. If the breaching party cannot prove the existence of such circumstances, it will not be exempt and must bear the penalty in accordance with the contractual agreement. This provision ensures transparency and prevents abuse of exemption claims as a way to avoid it obligations.

Above is the article “Penalty for Breach in Construction Contracts: Legal Framework and Conditions for Application” presented by TNTP. Should you have any questions, please contact TNTP for further assistance.

 

TNTP & ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL LAW FIRM

  • Office in Ho Chi Minh City:
    Room no. 1901, 19 th Floor Saigon Trade Center Tower, No. 37 Ton Duc Thang Street, Saigon Ward, Ho Chi Minh City
  • Office in Hanoi City:
    No. 2, Alley 308, Tay Son Street, Dong Da Ward, Hanoi City

The copyright belongs to: TNTP & Associates International Law Firm