Skip to main content

Commercial Dispute Resolution in Vietnam: 4 Methods Compared

| TNTP LAW |

Under Vietnamese law, a commercial dispute can be resolved by four methods: negotiation, mediation, commercial arbitration or the People’s Court. Article 317 of the Law on Commerce 2005 provides for these methods, and the parties are free to choose the one that suits the content of the dispute and their relationship. Only an arbitral award and a court judgment are binding and enforceable on their own; a negotiated outcome is not, and a mediated settlement becomes binding only after the court recognises it.

This article explains what counts as a commercial dispute in Vietnam, how each method works, how the methods compare, and what a business, including a foreign business with a Vietnamese counterparty, should do before and after a dispute arises.

What counts as a commercial dispute in Vietnam

Commercial disputes are conflicts (disagreements or conflicts) of rights and obligations between parties in the process of performing commercial contracts. They have three characteristics:

  • they are conflicts about rights and obligations between parties in a particular relationship;
  • those conflicts must arise from commercial activities;
  • they are mainly disputes between traders.

Under Clause 1, Article 3 of the Law on Commerce 2005, commercial activities are activities for profit-making purposes, including buying and selling goods, providing services, investment, trade promotion and other profit-making activities.

Goods are the objects of commercial activities. Goods include all types of movables, including those to be formed in the future, and things attached to land, such as trees.

The four methods of commercial dispute resolution

Article 317 of the Law on Commerce 2005 sets out three methods of dispute settlement: negotiation, mediation, and arbitration or court. In practice, commercial disputes are therefore resolved by four methods: negotiation, mediation, commercial arbitration and the court.

Each method differs in legal nature, procedure and order of conduct. The parties have the right to choose the appropriate method depending on the advantages it offers, how well it suits the content and nature of the dispute, and the goodwill of the parties.

1. Negotiation

Negotiation is a method of dispute settlement in which the parties voluntarily discuss, agree, self-mediate and resolve their disagreements, without the assistance or judgment of any third party.

The parties negotiate on the basis of specific arguments and legal regulations to find a resolution that aligns with their intentions. They may negotiate on their own or with the assistance of lawyers or experts.

The negotiation process is not bound by the law on the order and procedures for settlement.

The result of negotiation depends entirely on the voluntariness and compromise of each party. It is not legally binding, and there is no legal mechanism to ensure enforcement of what the parties agree during negotiation. As a result, the legal rights and interests of the parties may be difficult to ensure adequately.

2. Commercial mediation

Commercial mediation is a method of settling commercial disputes agreed upon by the parties, with a commercial mediator assisting them to settle the dispute according to regulations.

Under Article 6 of Decree No. 22/2017/ND-CP, a dispute is settled by commercial mediation if the parties have a mediation agreement. The parties may agree to mediation before or after the dispute arises, or at any time during the dispute settlement process.

The third party may be a commercial mediator or a commercial mediation organisation chosen by the parties, or a mediator designated by the commercial mediation organisation at the parties’ request. The mediator’s role is to persuade and encourage the parties to resolve the dispute in the best possible way. Whether mediation succeeds, however, depends largely on the agreement and will of the parties.

When the parties reach a mediated settlement, the settlement is binding only if the requesting party seeks recognition of it by the court, as prescribed by civil procedure law. For a fuller treatment of this method, see our guide to resolving disputes through commercial mediation.

3. Commercial arbitration

Commercial arbitration is a non-governmental method of resolution. An arbitrator, acting as an independent third party, settles the conflict by issuing an arbitral award that the parties must implement.

The parties’ request for dispute settlement must be supported by an arbitration agreement. The arbitration agreement may be made before or after the dispute arises.

Arbitration may be institutional or ad hoc. Institutional arbitration takes place at an arbitration centre, and parties typically prefer to name a specific arbitration centre in their contract. The parties may also agree on the arbitrator, the place of settlement, the applicable law and other matters. The steps of an institutional case are described in the dispute resolution process at an arbitration centre.

The arbitral award is final and takes effect from the date of issuance, without appeal. It is binding and enforceable, which is its main advantage over negotiation and mediation.

Arbitration also saves time and ensures confidentiality: the content of the dispute and the identity of the parties are kept private, which supports trust in commercial relations. Arbitration is the common trend for resolving international commercial disputes, so parties should consider providing for arbitration as the dispute resolution mechanism in their contracts.

4. Court proceedings

Settlement at the People’s Court is carried out by an adjudicating agency in the name of state power, according to strict order and procedures.

The court can only accept business and commercial disputes that fall under its jurisdiction, as specified in Article 30 of the Civil Procedure Code 2015.

To start proceedings, one party must file a lawsuit with the competent court, stating the facts of the case and its petition, together with relevant evidence.

Commercial disputes are tried under a two-level model: first instance and appeal. A judgment may be appealed or reviewed according to regulations.

A legally effective judgment or decision of the court is binding and enforced by the power of the State. If a party fails to comply voluntarily, the other party may request the competent civil judgment enforcement agency to enforce it.

Court proceedings also have limitations: a prolonged resolution time, complex procedures and difficulty in ensuring confidentiality.

Comparison of the four methods

Method Basis Third party Binding outcome Confidentiality
Negotiation Voluntary; no prescribed procedure None (lawyers or experts may assist a party) No; no legal enforcement mechanism Not specified
Commercial mediation Mediation agreement (Article 6, Decree No. 22/2017/ND-CP) Commercial mediator or mediation organisation Only after court recognition of the mediated settlement Not specified
Commercial arbitration Arbitration agreement, made before or after the dispute Arbitrator (institutional or ad hoc) Yes; final, effective from issuance, no appeal Yes
Court Lawsuit within the court’s jurisdiction (Article 30, Civil Procedure Code 2015) People’s Court Yes; enforced by the State; first instance and appeal Difficult to ensure

The choice between a court and an arbitral tribunal is often the decisive one. A detailed side-by-side analysis is available in the difference between dispute resolution in court and arbitration.

How to choose a method: practical guidance

Give priority to agreement

When a dispute arises, the parties should first try negotiation and mediation. These methods are usually quicker and more cost-effective, and they help the parties understand each other better.

If one party does not act in good faith, the other party may turn to arbitration or the court, depending on the specific circumstances.

Agree on the dispute resolution clause in the contract

No party wants a dispute when entering into a commercial contract. To anticipate one, the parties should set out the dispute resolution method when drafting the contract. When a dispute arises, they can then rely on that clause to resolve it effectively.

Arbitration in particular requires an arbitration agreement, and mediation under Decree No. 22/2017/ND-CP requires a mediation agreement. A clause that names the method, and for arbitration the arbitration centre, gives the parties a clear route. Points to check when drafting are covered in our notes on dispute settlement terms in commercial contracts.

Next steps for a business facing a dispute in Vietnam

  1. Review the contract’s dispute resolution clause: does it provide for mediation, arbitration (and which centre) or the court?
  2. Collect the contract, correspondence and other evidence that supports the claim.
  3. Attempt negotiation, alone or with a lawyer, and consider commercial mediation if the parties agree.
  4. If a mediated settlement is reached, request the court to recognise it so that it becomes binding.
  5. If the other party does not act in good faith, file a request for arbitration under the arbitration agreement, or a lawsuit with the competent court, stating the facts, the petition and the evidence.
  6. Once a judgment or award is in force and not complied with voluntarily, move to enforcement.

TNTP represents domestic and foreign businesses in negotiation, mediation, arbitration and litigation in Vietnam. Learn more about our commercial dispute lawyer service and process.

Frequently asked questions

Can a commercial dispute in Vietnam be resolved without going to court?

Yes. The parties may resolve it by negotiation, commercial mediation or commercial arbitration. Arbitration requires an arbitration agreement, and its award is final and binding.

Is a negotiated or mediated settlement binding?

A negotiated outcome is not legally binding and has no legal enforcement mechanism. A mediated settlement becomes binding when the requesting party obtains the court’s recognition of it under civil procedure law.

Can parties choose arbitration after a dispute has arisen?

Yes. An arbitration agreement may be made before or after the dispute arises. Likewise, a mediation agreement may be made before or after the dispute arises, or at any time during the dispute settlement process.

Can an arbitral award be appealed?

No. The arbitral award is final and takes effect from the date of issuance, without appeal. A court judgment, by contrast, may be appealed or reviewed according to regulations.

Which commercial disputes can the court hear?

The court can only accept business and commercial disputes under its jurisdiction as specified in Article 30 of the Civil Procedure Code 2015.

TNTP & ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL LAW FIRM

  • Office in Ho Chi Minh City:
    Room no. 1901, 19 th Floor Saigon Trade Center Tower, No. 37 Ton Duc Thang Street, Saigon Ward, Ho Chi Minh City
  • Office in Hanoi City:
    No. 2, Alley 308, Tay Son Street, Dong Da Ward, Hanoi City

The copyright belongs to: TNTP & Associates International Law Firm