Skip to main content

Construction Debt Collection in Vietnam: Key Issues for Creditors

| TNTP LAW |

When collecting a construction debt in Vietnam, a creditor should first identify which contractual link the debt sits on: investor to main contractor, or main contractor to subcontractor. Three issues then decide whether the debt is actually recovered: an agreed and signed debt amount, a debtor that is still able to pay, and a collection method that stays within the law.

This article covers those issues. It does not repeat the procedure itself; the full sequence from negotiation to litigation is set out in our guide on the steps for construction debt collection in Vietnam.

Why construction debts need particular attention

Debts arise frequently in construction, and recovering them has features that differ from other sectors.

Construction projects run over long periods. During that time, legal policies, prices and funding sources can change. Each change can affect the amount owed, the debtor’s ability to pay and the evidence a creditor will need later.

For a foreign contractor, subcontractor or supplier working on a project in Vietnam, these risks are added to the practical difficulty of following up from abroad. The considerations below are therefore best applied while the project is still running, not only after payment stops.

Who owes whom in a construction project

In the construction sector, debts typically arise among three parties:

  • project investors;
  • main contractors;
  • subcontractors.

Project investor

Under point a, Clause 1, Article 4 of the Bidding Law 2023, a project investor is an agency or organization that owns borrowed capital or is directly assigned to manage and use capital during the project execution; budget-using units; direct budgetary expenditure units; and centralized procurement units.

In other words, the project investor is the entity that directly invests capital and manages the use of that capital during the construction project.

Main contractor

Under Clause 26, Article 4 of the Bidding Law 2023, a main contractor is an organization or individual, or a combination of organizations or individuals, who enter into a bidding joint venture based on a joint-venture agreement to participate in bidding and directly sign the contract if selected. The joint-venture agreement must clearly define the responsibilities of the lead member and the common and individual responsibilities of each member within the joint venture for the entire scope of the contract package.

The main contractor is therefore the contractor named in the bid. It directly signs the procurement contract with the project investor and is responsible to the investor during contract performance.

Subcontractor

Under Clause 27, Article 4 of the Bidding Law 2023, a subcontractor is an organization or individual who signs a contract with the main contractor to participate in performing construction, consulting, non-consulting and related services of the goods supply or mixed contract package.

A subcontractor is therefore a contractor that signs a contract with the main contractor and carries out the related construction, consulting, non-consulting and related services under that contract.

How the debt chain forms

On a construction project, the project investor contracts directly with the main contractor. During construction, the main contractor may sign contracts with subcontractors to perform tasks within the project scope.

As a result, debts on a construction project typically arise at two points:

  • between the project investor and the main contractor;
  • between the main contractor and its subcontractors.

A creditor’s claim lies against its own contractual counterparty. Identifying that counterparty correctly is the starting point for every step that follows.

Typical construction debts

Debt between the project investor and the main contractor

The project investor awards the contract to the main contractor and is responsible for paying the main contractor in accordance with the contract.

Bad debts arise when the investor does not pay as committed. This happens, for example, where the investor neglects its capital plan and delays payment for completed works awaiting final settlement, or where it withholds payment in order to misappropriate capital.

Contractors facing this situation can find specific remedies in our article on what contractors can do when the investor pays late.

Debt between the main contractor and subcontractors

Subcontractors perform part or all of the project components under a subcontract with the main contractor. These debts typically relate to payment for construction components, raw materials and maintenance costs, among others.

Key considerations for effective construction debt collection

Because of the long duration of construction projects and the changes in law, prices and funding that can occur along the way, businesses should keep the following issues in mind.

1. Request periodic debt reconciliation

Effective debt collection requires an accurate assessment of the amount to be collected.

To reconcile debts, the parties can prepare a Debt Reconciliation Minute. This document records the debt value arising from the contract between the parties and is signed and stamped by both of them as confirmation of that position.

The Debt Reconciliation Minute serves as proof of the debtor’s payment obligation when the business demands payment. If negotiation fails and the dispute must be brought before a competent authority, it becomes an important document proving both the debtor’s payment obligation and the value of the debt the debtor must pay.

The other papers a claim usually relies on are discussed in our article on documents required for a construction debt recovery claim.

2. Check the financial status of the debtor

To know whether the debtor can pay, the business must know the debtor’s financial capacity.

Checking financial status helps the business identify which debtors are still capable of paying. The business can then focus its resources and finances on recovering from those debtors and avoid spending them on debtors that are no longer able to pay.

This check is not straightforward. Information about a company’s assets and profits is not publicly disclosed in Vietnam, except for listed companies. A business may therefore engage with other partners in its sector to learn about the activities and projects the debtor is involved in, and assess the debtor’s financial capability from that information.

3. Comply with legal regulations when collecting

Businesses must be aware of the legal regulations so that their debt collection activities remain lawful.

There have been cases where businesses used “gangster-style” debt recovery services, which are prohibited under the Investment Law 2020, and the matter led to criminal proceedings. For this reason, foreign creditors are better served by a law firm acting through lawful channels than by a collection agency. The prohibited practices are explained in our article on illegal debt collection in Vietnam.

A business has the right to demand payment from its debtor, but the demand must be made within the law. The lawful routes are:

  • negotiation with the debtor;
  • litigation, if negotiation is unsuccessful.

When initiating litigation, the business must study the legal regulations in order to make reasonable claims and choose the appropriate competent authority to resolve the dispute, so that its claim is accepted.

A business that has never brought a claim before a competent dispute resolution authority can use the services of a law firm to improve its ability to recover the debt and to conduct the litigation procedures effectively. This is particularly relevant for foreign creditors, who rely on a Vietnamese law firm to act for them locally; TNTP’s debt recovery services for foreign creditors are built for that situation.

Checklist for creditors

  1. Identify the debtor: the project investor, the main contractor or the subcontractor that is the creditor’s direct contractual counterparty.
  2. Reconcile the debt periodically and keep a signed and stamped Debt Reconciliation Minute.
  3. Assess the debtor’s financial capacity, including through partners in the sector, before committing resources.
  4. Collect only by lawful means: negotiation first, then litigation before the competent authority.
  5. Prepare reasonable claims and choose the correct competent authority before filing.
  6. Engage a law firm if the business has no experience of litigation in Vietnam.

FAQ

Who usually owes money on a construction project in Vietnam?

Debts typically arise between the project investor and the main contractor, and between the main contractor and its subcontractors. The investor contracts with the main contractor, and the main contractor may in turn contract with subcontractors.

Why is a Debt Reconciliation Minute important?

It records the debt value arising from the contract and is signed and stamped by both parties. It proves the debtor’s payment obligation and the amount owed, both in negotiation and if the dispute goes before a competent authority.

Can a creditor use a debt collection agency in Vietnam?

Businesses that used “gangster-style” debt recovery services, which are prohibited under the Investment Law 2020, have faced criminal proceedings. The lawful routes are negotiation and, if that fails, litigation, which a law firm can conduct on the creditor’s behalf.

How can a creditor check a Vietnamese debtor’s ability to pay?

Asset and profit information is not publicly disclosed except for listed companies. Creditors often learn about the debtor’s activities and projects through other partners in the same sector.

TNTP & ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL LAW FIRM

  • Office in Ho Chi Minh City:
    Room no. 1901, 19 th Floor Saigon Trade Center Tower, No. 37 Ton Duc Thang Street, Saigon Ward, Ho Chi Minh City
  • Office in Hanoi City:
    No. 2, Alley 308, Tay Son Street, Dong Da Ward, Hanoi City

The copyright belongs to: TNTP & Associates International Law Firm