International Debt Collection Case Study: Debt Recovered in New York
This international debt collection case study shows how TNTP recovered an unpaid debt in full from Company J, headquartered in New York, USA, for its Vietnamese client, Company K. The case moved from negotiation to a lawsuit in the New York State Court, and was settled through online mediation with a payment schedule that Company J completed within 02 months.
Geographical distance and differences between legal systems did not prevent recovery. The decisive factors were early pressure on the debtor, close coordination with local counsel in New York and timely use of information about the debtor’s planned dissolution.
Branch of TNTP & Associates International Law Company Limited (“TNTP”) provides legal services on dispute resolution and debt collection in fields such as commerce, construction, labor and intellectual property rights. Its lawyers and legal specialists handle bad debt collection both domestically and internationally.
Case at a glance
| Item | Details |
|---|---|
| Creditor (TNTP’s client) | Company K, a garment supplier in Vietnam |
| Debtor | Company J, headquartered in New York, USA |
| Claim | Unpaid price for garment products delivered under the Contract |
| Forum | New York State Court, online mediation with the Court Mediator |
| Stages | Negotiation, then litigation in New York, from 2021 |
| Outcome | Confidentiality Settlement and Release of Obligations Agreement; payment in full within 02 months |
Background of the dispute
Company K produces garment products using raw materials, fabrics, linings and accessories as specified by Company J. Company J then distributes the finished products to its affiliated stores.
Under the Contract, Company J had to pay Company K within the agreed period from the date it received the goods at the warehouse or location it designated in the US.
Company K completed delivery and its other obligations under the Contract. Company J did not properly and fully perform its payment obligations.
Obstacles in this cross-border debt
- Geographical distance: the creditor was in Vietnam, while the debtor, its assets and the competent court were in New York.
- Different legal systems: the claim had to be pursued under US procedural law, not Vietnamese law.
- Debtor evasion: Company J’s representative repeatedly avoided its payment obligations and delayed payment, and made unreasonable discount requests.
- Cash flow pressure: Company K had to pay its own suppliers for raw materials, so the delay hit its cash flow during the Covid-19 period.
- Risk of losing the debtor: Company J was preparing to dissolve without declaring its debt to Company K.
Similar issues arise in many cross-border claims. TNTP’s article on common debt collection challenges for foreign businesses in Vietnam looks at the same problem from the other direction.
How TNTP handled the case
From 2021, TNTP supported Company K in two stages: negotiation, and a lawsuit against Company J in the New York State Court.
Stage 1: Negotiation with the debtor
TNTP contacted Company J by email and phone and sent a Payment Request by international delivery. For many months, TNTP proposed payment options and plans that benefited both parties. Company J’s representative continued to evade and delay payment.
Company K’s delayed receipts also affected its timely payment to its suppliers. To speed up payment, Company K proposed to Company J and the suppliers that, since all parties faced difficulties due to Covid-19, Company K would reduce the Covid discount for Company J from 17.5% (Company J’s original proposal) to 7.5%, on condition that the suppliers also gave Company K a 7.5% discount.
Company J ignored these goodwill proposals and kept making unreasonable discount requests.
To protect its rights, Company K hired a debt collection agency in New York to verify Company J’s headquarters address directly and to serve the Payment Request on the Owner of Company J. After receiving it, Company J kept an unfriendly attitude towards Company K.
As negotiation did not produce a satisfactory result, TNTP proposed suing Company J in the New York State Court, and Company K agreed.
Stage 2: Selecting New York counsel and preparing the lawsuit
Through its research relationships, TNTP recommended several reputable law firms in New York State. On TNTP’s advice, Company K selected SH Law Firm, represented by Lawyer D, to protect its rights.
TNTP helped Company K compile the documents needed to file the lawsuit. It also studied US procedural law to discuss with Lawyer D the issues to clarify and a reasonable legal solution.
Based on the case and the amount Company K wished to collect, Lawyer D agreed with TNTP on a plan to negotiate with Lawyer S, Company J’s counsel, to resolve the debt in the most effective way for Company K.
Stage 3: Using the debtor’s dissolution to apply pressure
Through its information sources, TNTP learned that Company J was completing its application for dissolution. Company J intentionally did not declare the debt payable to Company K, in order to complete dissolution quickly and avoid paying.
TNTP asked SH Law Firm and Lawyer D to:
- search for information proving the concealment of the debt;
- find information on Company J’s asset status;
- prevent Company J from dissipating assets or transferring them to another legal entity (if any).
TNTP carried out these tasks by applying US law and reliable information from its sources.
Stage 4: Online mediation before the New York State Court Mediator
TNTP acted as Company K’s authorized representative in an online mediation with the New York State Court Mediator, Lawyer D and Lawyer S.
Over many days of discussion, TNTP and Lawyer D used the fact that Company J had applied for dissolution while concealing Company K’s debt. Applying US law, they pressed Company J to accept a plan to pay the debt in full under a specific Payment Schedule.
At the end of the mediation, the parties agreed on the content of the Confidentiality Agreement and agreed to sign the Minutes of Work, which were sent to Lawyer D for forwarding to the New York State Court Mediator.
Result: debt recovered in full
After the mediation, the parties signed the Confidentiality Settlement and Release of Obligations Agreement (“Agreement”). Company J had to follow the payment schedule and complete payment to Company K within 02 months. During this period, TNTP kept contacting Company J to request timely payment under the Agreement.
Company J paid according to the schedule. The entire amount under the Agreement was paid in full, and the dispute was closed.
Throughout the case, TNTP worked remotely from Vietnam with Company K, US counsel, the New York State Court and Company J, while keeping the work in the United States effective.
Lessons for creditors in cross-border debt recovery
- Start with structured negotiation: formal Payment Requests by email, phone and international delivery, plus realistic payment proposals, create a record before any lawsuit.
- Verify the debtor locally: confirming the debtor’s address and serving the Payment Request on the owner in the debtor’s country removes doubt about notice.
- Escalate when negotiation stalls: a lawsuit in the debtor’s jurisdiction changes the debtor’s incentives.
- Work with local counsel: a lawyer licensed where the debtor is located handles the court, while the creditor’s own counsel coordinates strategy, documents and communication.
- Watch the debtor’s corporate status: a planned dissolution or asset transfer can end recovery, but it can also become leverage if acted on in time.
- Follow up after settlement: monitoring each instalment until full payment closes the case.
For an overview of cross-border options, routes and enforcement, see TNTP’s guide to international debt collection from foreign partners.
FAQ
Can a debt be recovered from a company located overseas?
Yes. In this case, a Vietnamese creditor recovered the full debt from a company in New York, first through negotiation and then through a lawsuit and online mediation in the New York State Court.
Does the creditor need to travel to the debtor’s country?
Not in this case. TNTP managed the matter remotely and took part in the court-connected mediation online as Company K’s authorized representative, while a New York lawyer represented Company K before the court.
Who handles the court case abroad?
A local law firm in the debtor’s jurisdiction. Here, Company K selected SH Law Firm in New York on TNTP’s advice, and TNTP worked with Lawyer D on documents, legal issues and negotiation strategy.
Businesses facing an unpaid debt from a foreign or Vietnamese partner can contact TNTP about its debt collection services for creditors, from negotiation to litigation and settlement.



